Maths explained as a story: a puzzle first, then the formula
A maths idea sticks when it starts as a puzzle, works a real case and only then names the formula. The evidence, and how to make a whiteboard video that way.
By the Chasca team 7 min read
A maths idea sticks when it is told in the order people discover it: a puzzle they can’t answer yet, one case they can picture, the moment the rule breaks, and only then the name and the formula. That order has good evidence behind it, and it suits a whiteboard, where every line appears as it is said. Here is what the research says, why most explainer videos do the opposite, and how to make one that teaches the idea, not just the steps.
Why do so many students lose the thread in maths?
Often because they meet the rule before the reason. Results show how many are struggling. In PISA 2022, the mean mathematics score across OECD countries fell by a record 15 points from 2018, and on average 31% of 15-year-olds scored below the baseline level, the point at which students can use basic maths in simple real situations.
Below that line, a formula is a string of symbols to memorise. “A negative times a negative is a positive” and “anything to the power of zero is 1” are learned as facts that sound wrong, which is exactly why they are forgotten. The fix teachers have always used is to show why, and the question is how to do that in a few minutes of video.
Why start with a puzzle instead of the formula?
Because a question the viewer can’t answer yet makes the answer worth keeping. In a 2014 study in Neuron, Matthias Gruber, Bernard Gelman and Charan Ranganath asked people trivia questions and found that the more curious they were about an answer, the better they remembered it. Curiosity even helped them remember unrelated faces shown while they waited for the answer.
Classroom research points the same way. In a meta-analysis of 53 studies, Tanmay Sinha and Manu Kapur compared two orders: teach the idea, then practise; or let students try a problem first, then teach. Trying first led to better conceptual understanding, especially when the problem was designed well.
A video can’t hand the viewer a pencil, but it can do the next best thing: open on the puzzle (“This triangle has three right angles. That’s impossible.”), say plainly what the viewer will see by the end, and let them try before the answer arrives.
Why work a real case before the symbols?
Because the symbols mean more once the viewer has seen what they stand for. In a systematic review of concreteness fading, Emily Fyfe, Nicole McNeil, Ji Son and Robert Goldstone found that starting with a concrete case and fading step by step to the abstract one supports learning and transfer better than starting with symbols or staying with objects.
In practice that means a coin and a piece of string before 2πr, three penalties of −2 before (−3) × (−2), and the pattern 5³, 5², 5¹ divided by five each time before 5⁰ = 1. The formula arrives as the short way of saying what the viewer has just watched happen, and each symbol is named as it is written.
Why draw it by hand, as it is said?
Because a board that builds up with the voice gives the eye one thing at a time. In a study of 6.9 million viewing sessions of online course videos, Philip Guo, Juho Kim and Rob Rubin found that tutorials drawn by hand on a tablet held attention better than slides, and that the median time people watched was at most six minutes, however long the video. Selen Türkay found in 2016 that adults who learned physics topics from whiteboard animations remembered more and enjoyed it more than those given the same content as slides, narration or text.
Two habits make a board easy to follow. Draw the frame first (the axes, the empty table, the triangle) and fill it in as the narration reaches each part. And give each thing one colour for the whole video, so the orange dots inside a shape stay orange when they become the i in a formula.
When does a character help, and when does it get in the way?
A character helps when it carries the idea. Stories are understood and recalled better than plain explanations: in a 2021 meta-analysis of more than 33,000 participants, Raymond Mar and colleagues found narrative texts were remembered and understood better than expository ones. A character who asks “How can nothing be one?” gives the viewer someone to share the puzzle with.
But extras compete for attention. An overview of 29 meta-analytic reviews covering 1,189 studies found robust evidence that cutting interesting but irrelevant extras helps people learn. A mascot dancing beside every equation is one of those extras.
So the best maths explainers use a character for a few jobs and then step aside: to ask the question, to act out the real case the maths is about, to react where the rule breaks, and sometimes to close. The board does the explaining.
What does the Whiteboard maths skill do?
We make Chasca, so read this part with that in mind. We built the Whiteboard maths skill to make that kind of video from one sentence: a maths idea told as a story, drawn on a whiteboard by hand.
- You name one maths idea, such as “why any number to the power of zero is 1”, ask a question, or paste your own script to be read word for word.
- It writes the story in the order above: a hook in the first seconds, one real case with real numbers, the turn, then the name and the formula, why it works, and the whole idea in one line at the end.
- A hand draws every line as it is said. Equations are written step by step, graphs are plotted from their functions and constructions are drawn exactly, and the camera follows the pen.
- A character made for your idea appears only where it helps, in at most one scene in four and never two in a row: to ask the question, act out the example, react to the surprise or close. It is drawn in all its poses at once, so it looks the same each time, and the hand draws it like everything else. Choose “Board only” to leave it out.
- It comes out widescreen, one to ten minutes long, in any of the 79 languages Chasca narrates, right to left in Arabic.
It is made for maths teachers opening a new topic, tutors explaining the idea a student keeps getting wrong, and creators who would rather draw than film themselves.
For worksheets and exam questions solved step by step, the Maths problems skill is the better fit; we explain the difference in worked solution videos for maths.
What won’t it do?
- It won’t solve a sheet of problems. It explains one idea; the Maths problems skill solves problems.
- It won’t draw real people. History is told in words, and every character is made up for your video.
- It won’t put a character in every scene. That is a choice, not a limit: the board does the explaining.
- It won’t check your curriculum for you. Watch it through and check that the example and the words match how you teach the idea before you share it.
How do you make one?
- Pick one idea and the question behind it, for example “Why can’t you divide by zero?” or “What is pi, really?”.
- Open the Whiteboard maths skill and type it, or paste your own script and choose “My words, word for word”.
- Choose the language and the voice, and “Board only” if you want no character.
- Watch it through, then share it before the lesson, or set it as the question students answer next.
Your first two videos are free, up to a minute each, watermarked and with no card needed. After that, plans start at $9.99 a month; see pricing.
Sources
- OECD (2023). PISA 2022 Results (Volume I): The State of Learning and Equity in Education. OECD Publishing.
- Gruber, M. J., Gelman, B. D., & Ranganath, C. (2014). States of curiosity modulate hippocampus-dependent learning via the dopaminergic circuit. Neuron, 84(2), 486–496.
- Sinha, T., & Kapur, M. (2021). When problem solving followed by instruction works: Evidence for productive failure. Review of Educational Research, 91(5), 761–798.
- Fyfe, E. R., McNeil, N. M., Son, J. Y., & Goldstone, R. L. (2014). Concreteness fading in mathematics and science instruction: A systematic review. Educational Psychology Review, 26(1), 9–25.
- Guo, P. J., Kim, J., & Rubin, R. (2014). How video production affects student engagement: An empirical study of MOOC videos. Proceedings of the First ACM Conference on Learning @ Scale, 41–50.
- Türkay, S. (2016). The effects of whiteboard animations on retention and subjective experiences when learning advanced physics topics. Computers & Education, 98, 102–114.
- Mar, R. A., Li, J., Nguyen, A. T. P., & Ta, C. P. (2021). Memory and comprehension of narrative versus expository texts: A meta-analysis. Psychonomic Bulletin & Review, 28, 732–749.
- Noetel, M., Griffith, S., Delaney, O., Harris, N. R., Sanders, T., Parker, P., del Pozo Cruz, B., & Lonsdale, C. (2022). Multimedia design for learning: An overview of reviews with meta-meta-analysis. Review of Educational Research, 92(3), 413–454.
Video transcript What the narrator says in the 0:59 explainer above.
A negative times a negative gives a positive. We'll see why by removing penalties from a game. Each penalty costs two points: negative two. Three penalties change your score by negative six. That's three times negative two. Now let's reverse those three penalties.
Removing one penalty gives back two points. Removing three gives back six points. This is the key: removing a loss creates a gain. A negative multiplier reverses the change. So negative three times negative two equals positive six: three losses of two, reversed.
Why must that work? Multiplication still respects addition. Three plus negative three is zero. Multiply by negative two: still zero. Multiplying the parts must give that same total. Negative six plus our answer equals zero. Our answer must be positive six. A negative times a negative is positive.
Questions people ask
Because a question the learner can't answer yet makes the answer worth remembering. Curiosity improved memory for answers in a 2014 study in Neuron, and a meta-analysis of 53 studies found that letting students try a problem before being taught the idea led to better conceptual understanding than teaching first.
Start concrete and fade to the symbols. A systematic review of concreteness fading in maths and science found that moving from a concrete case to an abstract one supports learning and transfer better than starting with symbols or staying with objects.
Short. In a study of 6.9 million viewing sessions of online course videos, the median time people watched was at most six minutes whatever the video's length. One idea fits in one to three minutes.
The evidence is encouraging. In a 2016 study, adults who learned physics topics from whiteboard animations remembered more and enjoyed it more than those who learned from slides, narration or text, and hand-drawn tablet videos held learners' attention better than slides in a large study of online course videos.
Only when they carry the idea. Stories are understood and remembered better than plain explanations, but extras that are interesting and irrelevant cost attention. A character that asks the question or acts out the example helps; one that decorates every scene does not.
Yes. Chasca's Whiteboard maths skill turns one maths idea into a narrated whiteboard video that opens on a puzzle, works a real case, reaches the surprise and then writes the formula, drawn by hand as it is said, with a character in the few scenes where it helps.